5 Hypnosis Myths That Still Won’t Die

Filed under: Hypnosis Training

A group of adults stand in a dim training room with their eyes closed and faces tilted upward, while one smiling woman in the center looks straight at the camera with her eyes open.

Sometimes the most powerful suggestion of all is the one we accept without ever thinking to question it.

Hypnotism, the art and science of inducing and utilizing hypnosis, is filled with truths, half-truths, falsehoods, and absolute nonsense. It’s not surprising, in a field that grew out of mysticism and pseudoscience, to find so much silliness still lingering around.

I’m often asked who makes the best hypnotic subjects, men or women? Many have adopted the myth that women are more hypnotizable, but there’s no meaningful difference. In fact, the most responsive subjects are children between about seven and twelve, who often respond so readily that deepening is completely unnecessary.

Look Upward as High as Possible

Another pervasive falsehood is that we can stick someone’s eyes shut by telling them to close their eyes and look upward as high as possible. Supposedly, once their eyes are rolled up, they’ll be physically unable to open them.

This idiotic belief seems almost universal in certain hypnotic circles, and I particularly enjoy demolishing it in our Architecture of Hypnosis classes in Toronto.

I begin by asking all the men to stand up, close their eyes, and roll their eyeballs upward as high as possible. I then confidently explain that as long as they hold that position, their eyelids will remain firmly shut. And, sure enough, that’s exactly what happens.

Next, the women perform the identical experiment, with one important difference. I tell them that women have a natural ability to open their eyes while looking upward, something the men apparently lack. To everyone’s surprise, the women open their eyes quite easily!

Then I announce that I’ve got the sexes mixed up, and it’s actually the men who possess this remarkable ability.

We repeat the experiment, and this time the men succeed while the women can’t open their eyes. The class is generally astonished, which is precisely the reaction I’m looking for.

I then reveal that there was never any physical reason for either group to fail. The only thing I changed was their expectation.

And here’s the really interesting part. Nobody was hypnotized! There was no induction, no deepening, and certainly no mysterious physiological mechanism. The entire demonstration was accomplished through suggestion alone.

Stuck in Hypnosis?

Another hilarious myth is that someone can get “stuck in hypnosis” and never awaken. If that were true, considering the number of stage hypnotists performing around the world, there would be clinics filled with participants who simply never came out of trance!

Hypnosis isn’t some mysterious prison for the mind, with the hypnotist holding the only key. It’s an interactive psychological process involving attention, imagination, expectation, and suggestion. A hypnotist might have difficulty getting someone’s attention, but that’s hardly the same thing as trapping them in another dimension!

Helpless Truth-Telling Machines

Then there’s the persistent belief that a hypnotic subject will automatically reveal their deepest secrets, as though they’ve just received a good-sized injection of sodium pentothal.

This misconception is so widespread that two undercover police officers once approached me on the street. A certain criminal was likely to be at my nightclub hypnosis show that evening, and they wanted me to hypnotize him so they could take him backstage and interrogate him. Once hypnotized, they reasoned, he’d be compelled to tell the truth!

Naturally, I refused. Apart from the ethical and legal problems, their entire premise was wrong. A hypnotized person can withhold information, refuse to answer, make things up, and tell perfectly convincing lies.

Suggestion can also influence what people remember, or believe they remember. A subject might answer with enormous confidence without being remotely accurate. And that’s worth remembering, because confidence and accuracy are two entirely different things.

Taking Control of Another Person’s Mind

Perhaps the most damaging myth of all is that the hypnotist takes control of another person’s mind. It comes from George du Maurier’s 1894 novel Trilby, a wonderfully dramatic notion that Hollywood has exploited for decades. But it bears little resemblance to what actually happens in a competent hypnosis session.

The hypnotist isn’t exercising some supernatural power. Instead, the subject is actively participating in a process that can produce remarkable changes in perception, experience, and behaviour. Of course, expectations and social pressure can strongly influence how people respond, which is precisely why ethical practice matters so much.

We don’t need mystical explanations or absurd claims to make hypnosis interesting. After more than half a century, I still find it endlessly fascinating, not because it defies the laws of nature, but because it reveals just how extraordinary the human mind can be.

So here’s my challenge for you. The next time you hear an extraordinary claim about hypnosis, don’t simply accept it because it sounds impressive. Ask how they came to believe it, and how they know it’s true. And ask yourself what evidence supports it, whether there’s a simpler explanation, and how much might be suggestion, expectation, or plain old-fashioned mythology.

Because one of the most important things I’ve learned from studying hypnosis is that we humans are extraordinarily suggestible, and not just when we’re hypnotized.

Sometimes the most powerful suggestion of all is the one we accept without ever thinking to question it.

- Mike Mandel

Learn Hypnosis Online

With the Mike Mandel Hypnosis Academy.
World Class Training—Hypnotize Anyone.


Ready to Master Hypnosis? 

If you're serious about truly mastering hypnosis, you've just found the right place.

At the Mike Mandel Hypnosis Academy, we don’t rely on scripts. You'll learn the core principles that make hypnosis truly work—so you can adapt, improvise, and create lasting change with real confidence.

Whether you’re brand new to hypnosis or already a seasoned practitioner, you’ll gain the tools and deep understanding you need to take your hypnotic skills to the next level.

As a member, you’ll also unlock 24/7 access to our exclusive online practice rooms—a place where hypnotists from around the world meet to practice, experiment, and grow together in a supportive, feedback-rich environment.

Click here to join the Mike Mandel Hypnosis Academy today—and experience the difference between reading scripts and becoming a true hypnotist. Just $1 to get started.