A session can go perfectly and the client can still walk out believing it failed. In this episode of the Brain Software Podcast, Mike Mandel and Chris Thompson work through the things that go wrong during and after hypnosis, and arrive at an uncomfortable conclusion: almost every one of them was decided before the induction started. The client opening their eyes, the doubt loop afterward, the phone call three days later that says it didn’t work. None of those are technique failures. They are expectation failures, and the pre-frame is where you prevent them.
What You’ll Learn
- Disappointment takes work: Richard Bandler’s line, and the whole episode in five words. You need an expectation before you can be let down by one, which means the expectation is the thing you manage.
- Ninety seconds, not fifteen minutes: The pre-frame exists to give realistic expectations, not to sell hypnosis. Sell it and you raise a bar the session then has to clear. Go too long and you hand the client worries they never had.
- Eyes open is not trance over: Say “that’s fine, just close them again whenever you’re ready,” and carry on. Never ask if something is wrong. Better still, use it as fractionation and let them open and close twice more.
- “I don’t think I was hypnotized” is a mismatch, not a verdict: The client is comparing the experience to a model they brought with them. Don’t argue. Ask what they expected, then ask what actually changed.
- Set the criteria for success before you do the work: How will you know the problem is gone? Ask it in the interview. Without it, the client measures the wrong thing, and sometimes the fix is so complete they cannot remember having the problem at all.
Learn Hypnosis Online
With the Mike Mandel Hypnosis Academy.
World Class Training—Hypnotize Anyone.
Episode Summary
Mike opens with a line from Richard Bandler: disappointment takes work. You have to have expectations in order to be disappointed. From there the episode makes its argument, which is that most apparent problems during or after hypnosis are expectation problems that could have been prevented before the induction. A good pre-frame does not need to be long, and about ninety seconds is often enough. Its purpose is not to convince anyone that hypnosis is amazing. It is to tell the person what is about to happen and what is not. Hypnosis is focused attention, not sleep and certainly not unconsciousness. It usually feels surprisingly ordinary. They will probably hear everything, stay aware of where they are, and remember most of the session. They will not lose control, they cannot get stuck, and they are not going to give up their secrets. The beginner error runs the other way: building hypnosis up so high in the pre-talk that the experience can only disappoint.
The middle of the episode works through what happens when you skipped that step. The client opens their eyes. Nothing about eye position tells you what state someone is in, and the reasons are all ordinary, from testing whether they can, to a habit of vigilance, to simply surfacing for a moment. The response is “that’s fine, just close them again whenever you’re ready,” said without surprise, and then you carry on. Mike’s refinement is to use it: let them open the eyes again deliberately and the moment becomes fractionation. The same principle covers a client who shifts in the chair or scratches an itch. The script reader freezes and loses congruence. The hypnotist with a working hypnotic language generator says “and as you shift into an even more comfortable position, you can realize what’s changed,” and the session never breaks stride.
The last stretch deals with the aftermath. “I don’t think I was hypnotized” is a mismatch between expectation and experience, fed by a popular culture where being put under is the visible product. Dramatic depth matters far less than the therapeutic result, so the question is never “how hypnotized were you,” which they cannot answer, but “what changed.” When someone calls to say it didn’t work, don’t defend hypnosis, don’t explain the mechanism, and don’t lead with a free session. Ask what they expected to be different, then ask what is actually different, because meaningful change has often happened while the client was measuring something else entirely. Behavior frequently shifts before the feeling catches up. Sometimes the problem was serving a purpose, which is secondary gain and a session that found it has not failed. The practical fix sits earlier than all of this: establish the client’s own criteria for success during the interview, correct unrealistic expectations before they can become evidence of failure, and normalize the ordinary parts of trance in advance so the client has fewer opportunities to manufacture proof that nothing happened.
Additional Resources:
Great Hypnotic Work Starts Well Before the Induction
What if a Hypnotic Induction Goes Wrong?
Utilization and Incorporation in Hypnotherapy
How to Respond When Someone Says “I Can’t Be Hypnotized”
Click here to subscribe to this podcast in iTunes at OR just search for "Brain Software" in your favorite podcast app.
Follow Us & Stay Connected
- Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/mikemandelhypnosis
- X (Twitter): @MandelHypnosis
- Instagram: @mikemandelhypnosis